Table of Contents:

1. Introduction

2. The Dilemma: Maintenance Blues

3. Pros and Cons of Decommissioning an Inground Pool

- 3.1 Pros

- 3.2 Cons

4. The Impact of Removal on Home Value

5. Filling it in vs. Complete Removal

- 5.1 The Process of Filling it in

- 5.2 Full Removal

- 5.3 Cost Considerations

6. Landscaping Design Opportunities After Decommissioning

7. Choosing the Right Landscaper in Winnipeg

8. Outdoor Living Enhancements: Patios, Gardens, and More

9. Conclusion

1. Introduction:

Hey there! If you’re reading this, chances are you, or someone you know, has a backyard that’s looking more like a neglected water park than a serene oasis. Those inground pools that once brought joy and laughter can become a source of frustration when maintenance and replacement costs stack up, and equipment starts to crumble like an overcooked cookie! As life gets busier, the once coveted backyard swimming hole might become a burden rather than a blessing.

Today, let's tackle a hot topic: Should you decommission your inground pool and exchange it for a beautifully landscaped yard? We’ll untangle the pros and cons, evaluate how this decision can affect your home’s value, and dive into the wonderful world of landscaping options that await you once that swimmingpool is out of the picture. So grab your favorite beverage, and let’s dive in!

2. The Dilemma: Maintenance Blues:

Inground swimming features can be a slice of summer heaven, but as they age, owners often find themselves asking, "What was I thinking?" Here are some common maintenance woes:

- Wear and Tear: Pumps, filters, liners—oh my! Each component brings its own set of maintenance and replacement costs, particularly as they near the end of their natural lives. Replacing these parts can feel like a second mortgage. A few years back, I was looking at having to spend over $20 thousand to replace my liner and pumps.  As we weren't getting much use from it any longer, we decided to use that money to remove it completely and re landscape the yard.   Those are five year old costs.  I’m sure that in 2025 the numbers would be much higher.

- Chemicals and Cleaning: Constantly managing water chemistry to prevent algae growth, chlorine needs, and cleaning can feel like a never-ending science project that you never signed up for. According to the Association of Pool & Spa Professionals, the average annual maintenance cost for managing water chemistry can easily reach upwards of $3,000 and with inflation running the way it has been, that number is probably low.

-Seasonal Hassles: If you’re in Winnipeg like me, closing the pool each fall and reopening it in spring can feel like a seasonally impromptu workout, complete with heavy lifting and scheduling headaches.

When those sunny days fade, what was your backyard oasis could feel more like a money pit than a refreshing retreat. So, why not consider transforming that waterhole into your brand new backyard paradise?

3. Pros and Cons of Decommissioning an Inground Pool:

3.1 Pros

So let’s get into it—what’s the upside of saying goodbye to your in ground-pool?

1. Cost Savings: First off, money is always a motivator. By decommissioning your pool, you can save on maintenance costs, equipment repairs, and chemical treatments. **Ka-ching!** Consider that money saved as extra cash for your next vacation or possibly more landscaping features(think: gazebos, pergolas, outdoorkitchens).

2. Increased Usable Space: Who doesn’t want extra yard space? Depending on how you decide to landscape, that former swimming area can become a lush garden, a fire pit area, or even a cozy outdoor living room. Into your landscape design, you can incorporate, retaining walls and other hardscape elements, decks, gazebos, outdoor kitchens, and just about anything you can imagine.  So, let your imagination run wild!

3. Enhanced Appeal: A well-designed landscape design can significantly enhance your property’s curb appeal. A 2021 study by the National Association of Realtors found that about 74% of real estate professionals believe strongly that landscaping improvements impact home values positively.

3.2 Cons

But, wait! Before you get your shovel, let’s look at some of the potential drawbacks:

1. Initial Costs: Transforming the space can come with its own costs. You may need to hire landscaping contractors to help design and execute your vision, especially if you want a quality landscaping outcome.

2. Physical Labor: If you choose to tackle the decommissioning yourself, get ready for a workout! Removing and filling in an inground-pool is no small feat unless you enjoy aching muscles.

3. Regulations: Depending on your local policies, there may be regulations surrounding inground-pool decommissioning that require permits or specific methodologies for filling or removing.

4. The Impact on Home Value:

Now, let’s talk about the big elephant (or very large pool) in the room—how will this impact your home value?

Research shows that a well-groomed landscape can easily increase property value by 20% and more. With many potential buyers favoring beautiful yards over a pool that might become an expensive burden, you'll find that many buyers will value landscaping much more than the pool.

That said, it’s vital to remember the market in your area. If your neighborhood is full of homes with these water features that people still use, the removal may not significantly boost value. But if families are looking for low-maintenance yards, you may just have struck gold.

5. Filling in vs. Complete Removal:

Let’s peel away the layers on the options for getting rid of that inground-pool.

5.1 The Process of Filling in 

Filling in an inground-pool is often seen as a cost-effective option, but it’s not as simple as shoveling dirt (surprise!). Here’s the basic process:

1. Drain out all water: Ensure the water is completely removed first.

2. Fill in with Dirt: The area should be filled with clean dirt or gravel in layers, compacting each layer as you go to avoid settling problems later.

3. Resurface: You may need to reseed or install sod to level out the area and bring it back to life.  The possibilities and options are many.

5.2 Full Removal:

Complete removal is more involved and costly but offers some significant benefits:

1. Take It All: With full removal, you’ll get rid of everything—concrete and structure leaving you with a clean slate.

2. Usable Space: You may have more flexibility when it comes to landscaping. 

The possibilities are endless!

5.3 Cost Considerations:

Generally speaking, filling in a pool is less expensive than complete removal..

- Full Removal: This process will undoubtedly be the more expensive option. Ultimately, if you have the funds available, complete removal can pay off when looking to develop a versatile and appealing yard.

6. Landscaping Opportunities After Decommissioning:

Once it's gone, your backyard can truly transform. Here are some great ways to reimagine the space:

Garden Design

1. Flower Beds: Brighten the area with vibrant flower beds. Consider perennials like daylilies or peonies for a splash of color.

2. **Shrubs: Add depth and structure by layering shrubs! Consider using evergreens for year-round greenery. You can even design them to provide privacy!

Outdoor Living Spaces

1. Patios: Build a decorative patio area for grilling, dining, and friendly summer gatherings. Use durable paving stone or interlocking brick to create an attractive floor for your festivities.

2. Fire Pit: Create a cozy fire pit area surrounded by chairs and twinkling landscape lighting. Perfect for roasting marshmallows and sharing ghost stories!

3. Outdoor Kitchen: Take entertaining up a notch with an outdoor kitchen. Grill, dine, and enjoy your space every day—taking your backyard BBQs to the next level!

4. Water Features: Consider a small pond, fountain, or ornamental waterfall to create a serene atmosphere—a truly lovely complement to your backyard landscape design.

Choose landscape elements that match your style and lifestyle while enhancing the overall visual appeal of your home garden.

7. Choosing the Right Landscaper in Winnipeg:

So, if you’re not the DIY type (and no judgment here, I feel you!), it’s time to find some help! Here’s how to choose the right landscaping contractor:

1. Research: Start by browsing local landscaping companies in Winnipeg. Look for experience, specialties, and past project portfolios.

2. Reviews Matter: Check online reviews and ask for recommendations from friends or neighbors (especially if they’ve done work recently!).

3. Get Quotes: Most reputable landscapers will happily provide you with free estimates. This will help you budget and find the best fit!

4. Check Licensing and Insurance: Always, always confirm that your landscaper is insured and licensed for your peace of mind.

When you hire the right team, turning your backyard vision into reality becomes a collaborative and enjoyable experience.

8. Outdoor Living Enhancements: Patios, Gardens, and More:

With your landscaping plans underway, let’s sprinkle a few more ideas into the mix for that ultimate backyard transformation:

- *Pergolas and Gazebos: Create shaded areas for relaxation or entertainment with a stylish pergola or a cozy gazebo. Have fun with styles that match your home’s aesthetic!

- Landscape Lighting: Incorporate lights along pathways, around seating areas, and in garden beds. This will keep your outdoor oasis usable after dark and create a magical ambiance.

- Raised Flower Beds or Planters: Elevate your gardening game with raised beds or planters for veggies or ornamental plants. They look great and make gardening easier on your back.

- Sustainable Landscape Practices: Think about incorporating native plants in your garden design; they require less maintenance and attract local wildlife, providing biodiversity that enriches your yard.

By envisioning your outdoor space as a combined living area, you'll be able to enjoy the best of nature while maximizing functionality.

9. Conclusion:

The struggle is real when it comes to maintaining an in ground-pool as it ages, but don’t let that define your backyard! Instead, consider transforming that space into a stunning, multifunctional oasis that complements your evolving lifestyle and aesthetic.

By weighing the pros and cons of removing vs. filling in your  in ground-pooll, you can make a well-informed decision that can increase your home's value and enjoyment. Dive into landscaping possibilities that include gardens, outdoor living spaces, and cozy fire pits, and bring life back to your backyard.

If you've reached the conclusion that this is a bit much as a DIY project, you can always search words or phrases like landscaping near me, landscaping contractors Winnipeg, residential landscaping services Winnipeg or landscaping maintenance Winnipeg and you will be presented with a number of good professional landscaper options to choose from.  

If you're interested, Sunshine Maintenance & Landscaping would be thrilled to assist with your project.

In the end, whether you choose to fill in your pool or go for a complete removal, embracing quality and affordable landscaping can rejuvenate your space and positively impact your quality of life for years to come.

**Cautionary Note** on Landscaping in Winnipeg:

As you embark on your landscaping journey in Winnipeg, it's crucial to recognize the importance of understanding local regulations and permits before you dig in. The city of Winnipeg has specific guidelines and requirements that govern landscaping projects, and navigating these rules can be a daunting task for even the most enthusiastic DIY homeowner. This cautionary advice aims to provide insight into what projects may require a permit, the potential frustration of the permitting process, and why hiring a professional landscape contractor may ultimately be your best option.

Examples of Projects That Require Permits:

In Winnipeg, various landscaping projects necessitate specific permits from the city to ensure safety, environmental compliance, and aesthetic harmony. Common projects requiring permits include:

1. Major Grading or Site Alterations: If your landscaping plans involve changing the land's topography, such as extensive grading or earth moving, you will likely need a permit.

2. Retaining Walls: Building walls that exceed a particular height (generally over 1 meter) falls under regulations, as improper construction could lead to soil erosion or drainage issues.

3. Decks and Patios: Constructing a deck or patio that is freestanding or attached to a structure may require a permit, especially if it alters any designated utility easements. Decks that are designed to be more than 24 inches above the ground require a permit.

4. Fencing: While smaller fences and “Permitted Fences" may often be constructed without a permit, taller structures or those placed along property lines might need approval.

5. Water Features: Ponds, swimming pools, or significantly sized water features typically require permits to ensure they meet municipal safety standards.

6. Planting Trees: In some cases, planting trees within specific distances from utility lines or property lines requires a permit, particularly for larger species.

7.  In Winnipeg, whether you need a permit for constructing a gazebo or pergola typically depends on a few factors, including the size, height, and style of the structure, as well as its intended use.

Gazebos

- Permits Required:

 Generally, a gazebo that exceeds a certain height (often around 1 meter or 3.28 feet) or has a foundation may require a building permit. If it is considered a permanent structure and is within proximity to property lines or utility easements, you will likely need to seek approval from the City.

- Permits Probably Not Required: Smaller, portable gazebos or those that are less than a specific height (check local regulations for exact specifications) may not require a permit.

Pergolas

- Permits Required: Similar to gazebos, larger pergolas, especially those that are attached to a house or exceed height limits, may necessitate a permit. If they involve electrical work for lighting or fans, permits will also likely be required.

- Permits Probably Not Required: Smaller, freestanding pergolas often do not require permits, as long as they comply with local zoning regulations.

Projects That May Not Require Permits

On the flip side, many landscaping projects can be undertaken without the need for city permits. These include:

- Planting annual or perennial gardens

- Installing small-scale decorative features like bird baths or planters

- Adding mulch or gravel to garden beds

- Minor repairs or modifications to existing landscapes (dependent on local regulations)

Changes in Regulations:

It is essential to bear in mind that regulations and codes can and do, change over time. What may have been permissible last year could be subject to new rules today. For this reason, the best practice is to always check with the City of Winnipeg’s Planning, Property and Development Department before commencing any landscaping project, regardless of its scale. Up-to-date information can save you from potential fines or the need to redo work that doesn’t meet current standards.

Consider Hiring a Professional:

While the allure of a DIY project can be strong, it's important to acknowledge the intricacies involved in complying with city regulations. The permitting process can be time-consuming and frustrating, often leading to delays in your landscaping plans. Understanding the nuances of local laws, submitting the necessary documentation, and ensuring compliance can swallow up valuable time and resources.

By hiring a professional landscape contractor with expertise in Winnipeg's regulations, you not only expedite the process but also gain invaluable knowledge and experience that can enhance the quality of your project. Professionals often have established relationships with city officials and are familiar with the permitting process, thus minimizing potential hiccups along the way.

In conclusion, while landscaping can be an exciting and fulfilling endeavor, it requires careful consideration of local regulations and permits. 

Always consult the city before starting any project, and consider the long-term benefits of hiring a knowledgeable professional familiar with local regulations to navigate these complexities for you.

Don't miss out! Click here to subscribe today and get the latest blog posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Ready to take the next step? click here to contact us today to arrange a “no obligation” introductory phone call and let’s explore how we might be able to help you.

At Sunshine, we take a great deal of pride in delivering “top-notch” service.  But don't just take our word for it. Here's what our customers have to say about their experiences with us: 

• Ray and his crew are outstanding. I had the pleasure of using their services with a large commercial property. The service provided, and the detail and care that went into tending to every matter, was truly remarkable. Ray was always available and quick to respond to any calls or emails. His manner and Customer Service is excellent. I would highly recommend Sunshine to anyone looking for a commercial or residential property service.

Shelly S.                               

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

• I have been using Sunshine for a couple of years now, and without exception, it has been amazing customer care. Normal months for snow plowing and snow removal are November to March. For both years, Ray and his company have exceeded this boundary to provide great customer support, and clear our walks and back drive area. The great snowfall of October a couple of years ago, to just our most recent Manitoba snowfall. There has never been a day that snowed, that our walks weren’t cleared first thing in the morning. I would highly recommend this team!!

Michelle P.

Please NOTE: This Michelle P. review was provided directly from the customer's email **This is Not a Google Review**


COMMERCIAL REFERENCES:

Hannah Mailloux, Property Manager

Capital Property Management

hannah.mailloux@capitalgrp.ca

204-943-5700

Susan Wong, Property Manager

Karma Properties

susan@karmaproperty.ca

204-415-5712 ext. 201

Jean Reuther, Property Manager

D7 Property Management

jean@D7management.com

204-989-4211


 

If Sunshine can help you, contact us to to schedule a consultation:

Call or text Ray directly today: 204.229.9789

or email: ray.chastko@sunshinemaintenance.ca